Shipshewana Restaurants Nearby

Here are some of our favorite restaurants around the Shipshewana area.  

Bluegate Restaurant

Bluegate Restaurant located just 2 blocks west of the INn famous for their fried chicken, chicken and noodles, homemade bread, peanut butter spread, and PIE. Open Monday-Thursday 10:30am – 9pm, Friday and Saturday 7:00am – 9pm.

Das Dutchman Essenhaus

Located on the west of Middlebury on US 20. The Essenhaus is famous for their family-style and buffet suppers. Open Monday - Thurssday 6am to 8pm and Friday and Saturday 6am to 9pm.

East of Chicago Pizza

Signature Pizza's, oven baked subs, wings, sides and more. Located at 350 South Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN.

Sunday - Thursday 11am - 9pm, Saturday open till 10pm.

JoJo's Pretzels

Located downtown on the first floor of the Davis Mercantile famous for their hand rolled pretzels and homemade mustard. Open same hours as the Davis Mercantile.

Millie's Market Cafe

Located downtown on the top floor of the Davis Mercantile. Good little place to sit down for a relaxing lunch while sitting on the outdoor pation. Open same hours as the Davis Mercantile.

Rise'n Roll Bakery

An old fashioned bakery and premium deli, with other Amish goods and candy. They are best known for their cinnamom carmel donut, but offer many Amish country staples.


(574) 825-4032
West on Warren Gallery + Grill

Located at 200 West Warren Street in Middlebury, IN. Features indoor/outdoor dining with a unique and delicious menu. Tuesday - Saturday 4pm - 8pm